Monday, 13 July 2009

Celebrity Sudden Death Cults and Public Life

There was a moment during Michael Jackson’s funeral when millions of us around the world were supposed to come together and mourn the passing of genius. We were supposed to stop and share in an investigation of emotion conducted in anticipation of our yearning for a common bond of grief.

‘This is big’, the global media organisations said to themselves, and we had wall-to-wall carpet bombardment of the life and death of the King of Pop. News-providers across the world took up the challenge of connecting with what the premature death of a world-famous pop star means to people. To fill the pages and airwaves and screens with so much coverage, news executives must have decided, all at once, that: This is where the people come together; this is a moment when millions will all look in the same direction with unwavering scrutiny; the great lens of human civilisation will swivel and focus on the circumstances of Jackson’s death; the full force of the shared gaze of every eyeball will burn its way down through the experiences of all concerned; and thousands and millions will demand we explore every aspect of this celebrated person in our pages and broadcasts.

Jackson no doubt suffered a great deal of intrusion from the media while he was alive, but his death would become a seminal moment of networked reverence for his reconstructed memory. The king is dead; long live the myth of the king. The circumstances of Jackson’s death are murky but the many retellings of his last days suggest that the entertainer’s great achievements were in the past. Tabloid coverage publishes different theories by different members of the family or entourage. Broadsheet coverage assesses the cultural impact of Jackson’s legacy. This stuff and every kind of coverage in between screams ‘something important has happened; the world will never be the same again!’

Live broadcast of Jackson’s funeral on both BBC2 and Five shows how far up the pecking order of celebrity Jackson was, compared to the (relatively) private arrangements for Jade Goody. News and media organisations want big audiences, naturally. Superstardom produces a sudden cult of grief in the media because it gravitates to, and feeds off, events in which there is a demand for information. Jackson is in that category of celebrity of whom it can be said that they ‘touched millions of people in their everyday lives’.

The news corporations, particularly the BBC, once they had confirmed the initial reports, moved with great speed to replace their output with Jackson-related content. He was everywhere for days. The public displays of private grief by family and friends, making speeches for the TV at his funeral, completed the cycle of the sudden death cult. Jackson can now be remembered through the prism of the reaction to his death and how much the media told us his passing had ‘touched’ us.

Bit it was too much. Jackson has long existed in that celebrity hell where the brand barely survived the accusations and suspicions fame attracts. He was ‘Wacko Jacko’, he was beyond eccentric and he sent his kids out in public wearing veils. Whatever his past achievements, Jackson was a sad and lonely figure, much as Princess Diana was. She was openly ridiculed in the press the week before her sudden death and post-mortem rehabilitation into a different kind of saintly public figure. The transformation from ‘Wacko’ to King Michael of Pop is only partially complete. Accusations of abuse, drug-addiction and eccentricity notwithstanding, Jackson had no place in the national life and consciousness of the people like Di had, at least here in Britain. She was the outsider in the Royal Court, the quiet girl thrust into international diplomacy and the emotionally vulnerable victim of an uncaring establishment. Unlike Di, Jackson’s success was built on hard work and his reputation as the greatest pop star was earned by himself. He must take much of the responsibility for his fall from adulation as well. Jackson’s eccentricities, such as when he told Martin Bashir he liked children to sleep in his bed, were alarming. He acted as if he could not see why people would be alarmed and as if he no longer lived in anything like our world at all.

A person who enjoys the esteem of so many cannot rely on it when they appear to want to change themselves. It was who he was and what he achieved that made Jackson popular. He tried to change what he was with plastic surgery (accusations of his changing colour have always been denied). He did not try to regain his youthful looks, as is usual and tolerated; he tried to radically change his appearance. Jackson tried to become someone different from the person who won fame and fortune with their talents. It’s hard to forgive that or sympathise with that for most people.

It was all too much, the coverage. When contrasted with the recent anecdotes of watching the moon landings back in 1969, the funeral of Michael Jackson is barely an event at all in the sense that people really are thinking that the world has changed. Perhaps that sense of togetherness, that sense that, whatever happens, we are all in this and it affects all of us is something that cannot happen again.

Maybe there is just no reason any longer for people to surge together in great numbers. Recently, the financial system and its bankers, the political system and its politicians and now the press and its journalists have been pilloried for their behaviour in the name of the public interest. When the public is disconnected from, and suspicious of, these institutions and most others they can no longer play a role beyond that of the spectator who watches, cheers or boos and then exits.

Is the death of a pop star the last thing that the media can find to connect with the big, very general, public? Ersatz grief, mobilised by TV specials and special eight-page pull-outs is a tiny little piece of the common experience we once believed to comprise public life. The public, in whose name and in the name of whose opinion so much is done and justified, is barely engaged in any of the processes that directly affect it, but it is assumed still to feel, if not move much.

So media identify a big story and run with it. But that media identify this particular story as that big and that we the people are identified as that audience with those responses means that we are not really the public. We are not connected by experience of each other but by the emotion we may come to share about a cultural phenomenon of the broadest and most easily appreciated kind.

What else but the sudden death of a celebrity could change the TV programming, take over the news and create that shared spectacle in the space where we are all supposed to look? Probably not, say, a war breaking out or a big natural disaster in somewhere undeveloped. The exposure of wrongdoing by yet another set of personnel from a distrusted institution could not swing it. An unbelievably horrible crime such as the long-term imprisonment and sexual abuse of a woman by her father did not do it. The election of a black US president did, but one could say that Obama’s success story was interesting despite its political nature, rather than because of it.

Our society returns to normal service now that Michael Jackson has been interred. This week, accusations that News of the World hacks have been bugging celebrity phones may provoke politicians still smarting from the expenses scandal to re-regulate the press for the first time. One more public institution threatens to be rocked by another in a landscape of wobbly institutions. All of them wobble because the public in whose name they operate no longer trusts in them. Institutions such as banking, politics and the press were once central arenas where the future of society might be contested. If they pass away in their present forms, die off to become other kinds of public things, the public will not even be there for the funeral.

Monday, 29 June 2009

Notes on booze ban activism

Brighton is a booze ban city. Drinking alcohol is not actually illegal, but possessing it can result in its seizure by police and community officers. This is a terrible idea legally, but the powers the Home Office has given Brighton and Hove City Council, and its abuse of them, is a socially corrosive crackdown on public culture.

This morning I saw my friend and colleague live on BBC1 discussing the alcohol-control zones that we had been discussing publicly and campaigning about this week.

Dan Travis produced and chaired a discussion on the Brighton booze ban on Thursday evening. It featured Josie Appleton, director of the Manifesto Club, and me, from The Brighton Salon. On Saturday afternoon, a dozen or so of us had a “protest picnic” on the beach near Hove.

Dan had been interviewed as part of The Times’ coverage (1) of a report Josie published on Thursday called “Robbed by the Police: Alcohol Confiscation and the Hyper Regulation of Public Space” (2).

Dan made long and determined efforts to involve someone from Brighton and Hove City Council to come and discuss the issue for three weeks. Needless to say, the BBC’s This Morning crew found someone to represent the council’s view at much shorter notice. The lady’s name I didn’t catch (link if the clip becomes available on BBCi), but I think she made two very important concessions to our objections about the law.

Targeting the lager, not the louts

A Designated Public Place Order allows police and community safety officers (or police community service officers) to confiscate alcohol, even unopened containers, on suspicion that the alcohol may be drunk in public within the zone and result in some form of nuisance or disorder. Refusal can result in a fixed penalty for disorder of £50, arrest, fines of £500 (soon to rise to £2,500) and a bail condition order forbidding a person drink in public.

Dan related how his unopened cans were seized by PCSOs after visiting the off-licence on his way home. The council spokeswoman said that the law was supposed to be targeted at people likely to offend and street drinkers, who had been causing problems for local residents.

Brighton’s Crime and Disorder Reduction Partnership comprises many different groups from the authorities, residents and commerce and has had some cool ideas, such as the chill-out zone where people can leave their worse-for-wear friends behind in safety. It is a hub in the spider’s web of agencies that aim to make our city safer. Its website provides local information and statistics on crime, disorder and anti-social behaviour upon which is based explanation of the policies being pursued.

On This Morning, the Brighton council spokeswoman quoted a CDRP survey from 2003 that showed 89% of people in Brighton would welcome greater powers to deal with anti-social drinking, citing street drinkers as a particular problem for the city.

The CDRP info on crime and disorder incidents stretches back only to 2005 online, but some of the results of different surveys go back six years. Since 2003 the situation looks very different (3).

Plotting the percentage of respondents “feeling that people being drunk or rowdy in area [is] a problem in their area” over four surveys, a graph shows 63.9% felt this way in 2003; 49.2% in 2006; 37.2% in 2007 (the year I believe the alcohol control zone began to be enforced); and 33.9% in 2008.

This perception of the problem of on-street drinking was in decline when the council turned most of the city into an alcohol control zone. Perceptions about street drug abuse and dealing fell sharply during this period as well, so perhaps the various agencies were doing some things right.

Police recorded incidents of social disorder between April 2005 and April 2009 show seasonal variation between a low of about 1,000 per month in winter to a high of between 1,400 and 1,500 in summer.

There were about 15,000 incidents between 2008 and 2009. In that time, only 13 ASBOs were obtained in the city.

There has been a surge in the number of street drinkers. There were, on average during quarterly counting exercises, 27 in 2006/07, 32 in 2007/08 and 48 in 2008/09.

The number of violent crimes since April 2005 has shown seasonal variation but appears to be on a trend downwards. A peak shows in summer 2006 possibly, the site suggests, as a result of the World Cup, although this is not explained.

All violent crimes fell by 13.9% and 21.8% and “A&E assaults outside the home” fell by 15.5% and 5.6% in 2007/08 and in April to September, 2008.

Tough on crime; tough on stuff that’s nothing to do with the causes of crime

The figures from the CDRP website suggest that there is neither a perception of crime nor an increase in actual crime that requires draconian powers.

Brighton and Hove City Council applied this power of alcohol confiscation across most of the city but diagrams of the distribution of both public place violence and recorded incidents of social disorder, arranged by council ward, show there are hot spots, unsurprisingly in central and coastal areas.

The council has applied Home Office-derived powers across most of its territory that were intended by central government only for particular areas of concern. At the same time, other, less headline-worthy initiatives appear to have been having some effect.

The perceptions upon which justification for new powers was based no longer apply.

Street drinkers targeted as contributors to the problem, perceived and in reality, seem to have little effect on it. PCSOs are arbitrarily targeting random persons with drink, not people whose drinking is a problem.

Even if problematic drinkers were targeted by these powers, how would a cop or a community non-cop be able to tell they were going to offend before they have actually done so?

Hyper regulating the public destroys public space

If the random targeting of people that makes possession of alcohol an inarguable offence were not bad enough, the council also has the power to suspend its DPPO and licence alcohol itself for temporary public events such as fetes, farmers’ markets, carnivals and so on.

Through its licensing powers, the council can now control what events can or cannot have alcohol, effectively deciding what events, formal or informal, may or may not go ahead. The council always had this power over premises and public areas it owned, but they are now extended over most of the public space of the city, regardless, and can be applied instantly in response to any improvised appearance by numbers of the public.

The operation of the DPPO was in itself anti-social but, coupled with the same authority’s licensing powers and its zeal in persecuting any unlucky drinker, a sinister potential to close public space down entirely has been brought into existence.

The council was understandably sheepish about coming to defend treating people like sheep for our public meeting. Dan’s appearance on TV winkled out a spokesman, however, and that shows that the little protest we made and the meeting we called on the issue were well worthwhile.

After discussing many aspects of the booze ban in Brighton last week, it struck me that many of us were thinking about how this law might be fought in a legal way. I think that bringing it out into the open and forcing the council to defend it, politically, has a much better chance of reversing the DPPO sooner than any challenge in the courts.

The Manifesto Club is organising further protests against the hyper regulation of public space as part of its Freedom Summer. Read Josie Appleton’s report and see their events at http://www.manifestoclub.com/.

For an article by me on the depersonalisation of the public in Brighton, see http://www.facebook.com/l/;http://seandavidbell.blogspot.com/2009/06/confiscating-alcohol-turns-people-into.html

For further coverage and other events organised by The Brighton Salon, see www.thebrightonsalon.com and www.thebrightonsalonarena.com

1. “A glass of wine with your picnic? It’s against the law”, Bennett, R., and Ford, R., p12, The Times, 25/06/09 or view at http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/law/article6571617.ece

2. http://www.manifestoclub.com/

3. All the CDRP’s data I have quoted can be viewed and downloaded from pages on its “Safe in the City” website. Start here: http://www.safeinthecity.info/?q=priorities/alcohol

Tuesday, 23 June 2009

Democracy isn't something you watch anonymously

So what if NightJack's blog isn't up any more? So what if anonymous bloggers can't use the law to protect their identities?

The Guardian's director of digital content, Emily Bell, deplored the news that the High Court would not uphold DC Richard Horton's right to remain unnamed. The detective had obtained a court order preventing The Times from naming him that was overturned by Mr Justice Eady.

In a comment headed "A bad day for bloggers and democracy" (MediaGuardian, p6, 22/06/09), Bell said The Times' opposition to the injunction silencing it has resulted "in the closure of a blog and the disciplining of Horton by the force".

How ironic, Bell said, that just as Iranian protestors "harnessed the power of the web" to organise demonstrations, the public can theoretically no longer publish anonymously.

What on earth have Iranian demonstrators got to do with a cop who uses a court injunction on the press so he carry on being a detective and a blogger?

Those campaigning secretly against a repressive regime are anonymous to prevent their arrest by authorities. NightJack wanted to remain anonymous so he could carry on writing about arresting people.

You see what this reasoning does: Unnamed bloggers are trying to overturn a general election result in Iran and are organising resistance to repression; we're unnamed bloggers so we must be freedom fighters too!

Those nasty journalists have exposed NightJack's identity so they must be repressive - just like the Iranian government!

"If a citizen journalist, or a blogger, or a witness is only allowed to remain anonymous if published under the protection of a news organisation, it suggests yet again that courts have some way to go before understanding the full impact of democratised media," said Bell.

First, get past that tiresome "if you disagree with me, you don't understand me" bullshit from a digital enthusiast, and check the reasoning. NightJack used a court to try and remain anonymous - a court!

It just doesn't matter usually who anonymous bloggers are. They write crap that no-one reads. In this case, because it was a crime blog, apparently published by a detective, there was great legitimate interest in who wrote it.

Furthermore, journalists, and everyone else, are severely restricted in what they can publish about an ongoing case, especially if the charges are serious enough to warrant the use of a jury.

Under the strict liability rule, a news organisation, or blogger, or "citizen journalist", may not publish anything that poses a "serious risk" of "substantial prejudice" to the trial of a case. As a contempt of court, heavy fines and prison sentences for violation of the strict liability rule may be imposed.

A police blogger just gets a slap on the wrist from the force, apparently.

NightJack's blog was entertaining and well-written, but it wasn't whistle blowing, or a ruthless expose of police procedure.

What would be the alternative for a "witness" to publishing through a news organisation and opting for the protection from identification that way? Anonymous accusations don't work for police and the courts; you have to ask for their protection.

And Suzanne Breen, who faced prison when police tried to force her to hand over information on the Real IRA, won her right to protect her sources on the basis she might be killed, even though the judge accepted the information she had would be useful to police hunting the terrorists.

Despite all this, Emily Bell saItalicys that, in future, whistleblowers and witnesses will think twice about going to The Times because it "thinks it is in the public interest for anonymous writers, sources and citizens to be exposed". Sources should worry about The Times?

I worry about where The Guardian gets its idea of what public opinion is. Dredging up the nameless bottom feeders of the blogosphere and presenting the silt as public opinion is only sort of like finding a source.

A serving cop who wrote what he liked, used the court to gag the press when he was found out, then gave up writing and accepted disciplinary sanctions because he agreed he acted unprofessionally is not a good example of "democratised media".

Democracy is something you stand up for and take part in. Iranian protestors and many, many others throughout the world, do not just sit at their screens publishing a stream of unconsciousness under a silly name. It takes a lot more than that to win the littlest bit of democracy and allowing courts to silence newspapers was never going to help them.

To even imagine that the opportunity of being able to publish to others is so dependent on secrecy and anonymity, in this society, that courts should protect bloggers from the nasty press, shows the thing most treasured, the thing that Emily Bell wants most to protect, is not democracy, not freedom of expression and not even independence from news gatherers.

The most precious thing is the mode of expression, how you have your say not what you say. The independence that only flourishes in secret is called isolation and that makes co-operation difficult, let alone democracy.

Friday, 19 June 2009

It doesn't stand up, Belle de Jour

The exposing of the identity of the police detective blogger, NightJack, has highlighted a serious problem with “citizen journalism”.

Detective Constable Richard Horton, who published an award-winning blog on his experiences as a Lancashire cop dealing with the rough end of the criminal justice nightstick, had won an injunction against The Times preventing it naming him after a reporter figured out his identity. The High Court has quashed that, Mr Justice Eady remarking that a blogger “has no reasonable expectation of privacy” (“’Ello ’ello ’ello. Blogging detective unmasked”, The Guardian, p3, 17/06/09).

Another uniformed blogger, Tom Reynolds who publishes Random Acts of Reality about his experiences as a London ambulance worker, says the ruling is similar to making journalists reveal their sources. His point is that, as journalists who are their own sources, bloggers need privacy to be honest and protect them from the consequences of what they say.

The presumably occasionally uniformed sex-working blogger, Belle de Jour, whose writing turned into books and a TV series starring Billy Piper, weighed in with the announcement that journalism was dead and that it now was killing off the bloggers who had replaced it.

“We need people to tell the truth, to speak truth to power. Once that role was served by journalists. No longer,” she said in The Guardian (“A Dangerous Precedent” p33, 18/06/09).

Citing the need for privacy of bloggers in repressive parts of the world, and the similar need for whistleblowers in our own society, Belle asserted that there’s a need for anonymity for bloggers, even if what they do goes public.

NightJack - I mean DC Horton - took a disciplinary hearing from the force rather than attempt to benefit financially from his writing, as Belle did. Accepting that his conduct had been unprofessional, his blog has been stopped and its archive has gone.

Belle de Jour, whose identity is presumably either known or not important to the journalists who dish out comment space in The Guardian, accused The Times of destroying the NightJack blog because it must have contained something “incendiary”.

Belle has this issue back to front. The police blogger tried to use the power of the court to silence a journalist. The Times wanted to publish the identity of a person who had won the Orwell blogging prize and had been reportedly approached by agents and publishers. There was immense interest in his identity because of his own blog.

Lancashire senior police officers might have considered allowing NightJack to continue, as ambulance bosses have encouraged Reynolds, but it might also have devalued his writing once the public knew of the force’s permission. The DC decided to stay with the force anyway. Presumably, he contested the revelation of his identity so that he both blog and remain a detective.

The professional reporter that uncovered his identity has no special powers or warrant card, as DC Horton has. Really, it was always going to be a matter of time before the detective was named because he had initially and unavoidably placed himself within a relatively small group of people among whom he could not have long hidden once a journalist started looking.

It is a pity that the blog has stopped because it was entertaining and well-written. But that doesn’t mean that it’s a good idea to slap reporters with court orders under the assumed name of freedom.

When you are fed some nonsense in a paper or on TV by a journalist, you know who they are and who they work for. You might complain, correct and respond in all manner of ways because the journalist reports to the public with a responsibility to the public (however badly) and news organisations must stand by their stories. The accountability of journalism to its public is very, very imperfect, but there is some.

Belle do Jour used The Guardian to promote her obituary of journalism. For her, freedom to blog rests on anonymity, of course, so she is not accountable for what she says. Until now, it never really mattered what she said, because it was just about her and her sad clients.

Bloggers in repressive countries comprise an underground press that writes and publishes under extremely difficult conditions. What they do to oppose their regimes has absolutely nothing to do with blue-light stories from the front line (or red-light revelations).

People, who risk imprisonment in, say, Iran for reporting their experiences on blogs are in no way assisted by the silencing of journalists by courts in this country.

The logic that bloggers need anonymity is faulty. Undercover work in our society can be unfair to the whistleblowers who collaborate with journalists; they have breached confidence with their employers, albeit in the public interest. To expect a blanket court ruling of privacy from journalists, so that one can carry on anonymously commenting, reveals how narrow the interests of a personal blogger can be.

Even a really terrible journalist has some standard by which copy will be judged, some concept of the readership that should be informed or represented.

Does honesty rely on no-one knowing who you are? In the small world of the western “citizen journalist”, maybe it does. The secrecy that protects some anonymous bloggers from reprisals protects all from having to take responsibility for the truth of what they say. Anonymous writing in newspapers used to come with a name and address supplied tag – indicating that the author was known but their details were withheld for some reason. That is protecting a source. Purely anonymous submissions were once binned. Now newspapers frequently publish anonymous material with the online tag in place of the name. Journalists should not give up on their own jobs by presenting the fall-out of the blogosphere as public opinion.

If you speak out in public, and you have something interesting and original to say, you will not be able to hide behind a blog tag.

The public wants to know who’s poking it; arousing curiosity about something invites curiosity about you and what your motives are.

Try giving a speech at Speakers’ Corner in a ski mask.

Public scrutiny is the essence of journalism and a court should never be used protect anyone from that, as NightJack demanded.

Belle de Jour, after your comment in print I would have said that you should not give up the day job. But I want you to give that up as well.

Confiscating alcohol turns people into drunken children

Among the injustices in the world and of all the poor political decisions we must endure, a local by-law that allows police and others to confiscate alcohol seems trivial.

It is equally true that within the booze control zones around Brighton and Hove there are many more grave social problems than those caused by alcoholics taking over parks and seafront areas and those caused by binge-drinking.

Brighton and Hove City Council has many, many organisations and policies aimed at improving the quality of life for residents, among them the Crime and Disorder Reduction Partnership that is behind the Safe in the City intervention.

Some of these policies actually seem to work.

One good idea was the creation of a safe chill-out zone where people can park their friends who are the worse for wear. Others who have had too much drink or too many drugs may find sanctuary from the risks that insensible and intoxicated people otherwise face on the streets at night.

But the use of special powers granted by the Home Office to confiscate drinks, on suspicion, from anyone, turns much of the town into a specially policed chill-out zone. Within the confines of a sanctuary for the inebriated, it's useful to treat the clients as people who cannot properly make decisions for themselves and care for them.

To treat anyone, though, as incapable has a consequence far beyond the relatively trivial loss of their drinks. As people privately enjoying the public space we all must accept some standards of behaviour to get along. We have rights under the law that normally protect us to some extent from having to justify what we do unless we break laws. If we do not all know what all the laws are we at least know when they are likely to be enforced.

There is no case so far in Britain of anyone providing a 'reasonable excuse' for refusing to hand over drink to a police officer, support officer or even park/beach ranger. Here in Brighton and elsewhere there is anecdotal testimony that security guards and doormen have also adopted the Home Office's new powers.

This trivial regulation, probably intended to target street alcoholics, trouble-makers and underage drinkers, can at one stroke criminalise and depersonalise anyone it is used against.

Having committed no offence, and there being no actual offence for a normal court to consider except that of refusal to hand over drink (and therefore implicitly accept an offence might have been committed, by oneself), a person becomes the object of authority, like a small child.

The people, associated with problem drinkers simply because they are enjoying a drink, lose their normal rights as persons and are left unable to contest the suspension of those rights.

The confiscation of a can of beer may be trivial materially, but to agree to it is to accept the suspension of what you are as an individual with both rights and responsibilities in society.

Many people do not accept that the threat of terrorism justifies the suspension of our rights. They feel that to drastically alter our way of life in response to terrorist violence would grant them an ideological victory over us that would help them justify their actions.

If our response to the more constant, low-level violence of street disturbances by the drunken minority is to infantilise us all, to turn local society into a chill-out zone, we will reap what we sow. People treated like children by authority are encouraged to behave like them.

I will speak on this issue at The Brighton Salon on June 25 at 7pm at The Terraces, Marine Parade.

I will look also at how the demonisation of drink has taken on a startling new character recently and finding further praise for policies that seem to work. Joining me is Josie Appleton of the Manifesto Club, which has started a survey of what is actually happening in these alcohol control zones.

Come along and have drink, listen to what we have to say and take part in a full and frank discussion.


Wednesday, 20 May 2009

Politics isn't working, so don't reform it

“Public dissatisfaction with politics has never been greater: a national debate is needed on what must change.”

The Guardian is launching a discussion thread on its website entitled “A New Politics” with the above statement. The public can respond there on the contributions by the paper’s commentators. Trawling through the reader’s responses, there seems little chance of any kind of consensus on just what reforms of the political system would actually work.

Most respondents call for some kind of restraint on MPs, either with new bodies, a constitutional limit set on their powers or in many other ways, some funny, some bloody.

It’s all very well to encourage discussion and invite new ideas, but the job of politicians is not just to represent the people but to lead them. The sovereignty of Parliament is a very old idea but a good one. The representatives of the people, the MPs, are not constrained by anything that a previous Parliament, or monarch, has done in the past. This tradition is part of Britain’s unwritten constitution because it means that the body that runs the country looks only to its own people and their future. It can reverse or abolish anything that has gone before and it can drop or revive a tradition if it decides to.

Calls for a written constitution are understandable when one looks at those democratic countries that have enshrined certain rights and freedoms in their constitutions. Abolishing the Lords and the Monarchy are also great ideas. Unfortunately, to embark on such a project right now would be counter-productive.

Any constitution enshrining our rights for ever, written now, would be profoundly affected by mistrust of political parties and their politicians and the mutual suspicion of the public and their representatives. Rights of all kinds have been undermined in several ways recently. To fix them permanently now, in a constitution that must be designed to be difficult to change, would probably result in more control of people’s activities and more surveillance of their lives, not less.

To limit the power of MPs also would be a backward step. They are elected by the people and anything that constrains their power constrains the will of the people, quite literally. A constitution written now, without some corresponding input of genuine public opinion that is refined and discussed, would not have the support or consensus that a constitution needs to be workable. It would not be representative of the interests of the people. Without a long, hard discussion throughout society of what the principles of a written constitution should be based on, anything produced would be a knee-jerk reaction to the current preoccupations of the political class and the commentariat. It could not represent the people unless they were involved.

Perhaps a constitution might seem to be a good thing to reinvigorate a process of political engagement by the public. The underlying reason for the problems experienced by the political class (and media organisations, too) is that they have become the technical managers of a system that required no real public debate.

The public is certainly ready for change, A New Politics and a national debate, but the politicians and the parties and the gatekeepers of national discussion, the media, are certainly not. With hard-won consensus comes real leadership and nobody is ready to risk that yet.

A process of the reintegration of the public into politics and debate would be off to disastrous start if we jump straight into the deep end with a written constitution. The political classes and their communication facilitators need some practice before working up to a constitution.

Let’s all start with a relatively simple one – sort out the economy. If any politicians can rise to this challenge they will have engaged the people and learned to lead them. Then we could start the hard stuff.

Attacking MPs is journalistic cowardice

Billions have been spent on banks that will not lend. The crisis in finance means the next government, whether under David Cameron or Joanna Lumley, will have to make savage cuts in public expenditure. But no politicians are talking about any of that until after the next General Election while the champions of the people in the media are letting them get away with it. They are checking receipts for second homes and moats.

Shaken politicians and excited reporters say public anger and disgust may destroy the foundations of trust that underpin democracy. Except that opinion polls don’t support this view. Support for all parties has hardly varied during the course of the affair so far.

The public is imagined in the minds of politicians and Westminster journalists as an unstable and unpredictable rabble. They fear the anger of the mob, but how, exactly, has this anger been expressed? A satirical website planted a pound-shaped flowerbed in an MP’s garden and some more were booed on Question Time. The public may be revolted, but it is not revolting. Some polls say people see the expenses issue as peripheral.

The media, led by The Daily Telegraph, has been humiliating MPs as part of a long-running feud. There is a strong blame culture involving the politicians we vote in to represent us directly and the media that scrutinise, edit and communicate what they do in our name. “Village” is an apt description of Westminster if it describes a parochial, paranoid place where scandal results from everyone knowing your business.

Both antagonists have trust and legitimacy problems. The media, especially its biggest British organisation, the BBC, can’t do anything right. Newspapers are declining, commercial TV is going broke and local media are endangered species. Journalists collecting and editing information on behalf of the public are representative, in fact, of the organisations that sell and exploit that information. Reporters must chase circulation and eyeballs, not the big picture.

Politicians are suspicious of the reporters’ agendas and try to channel and control communication through to their voters. The reporters must be seen to work under Jeremy Paxman’s maxim: “Why is this bastard lying to me?” The public, endowed with the many eyes and arms of the media, becomes capable of bringing about the downfall of politicians without recourse to the voter.

The politicians’ refusal to discuss the near future is cowardly.  The Tories, as the probable next government, are particularly craven. they are not trying to win the next election, ther're just sitting back, waiting for Gordon Brown to lose it. They spinelessly waffle about austerity while keeping quiet about unpopular policies.

Political journalists cannot even prod the Prime Minister-in-waiting to say what he will do in power. The media, led by that vanguard of the people, the Telegraph, take the government to task for its decoration bills while it runs up the biggest public debt ever – after a 15-year boom.

MPs’ expenses have taken a long and winding route to become a strange form of public property. Investigative journalist and author Heather Brooke tried to use the Freedom of Information Act to publish MPs’ expenses in 2004 and received such a run-around she ended up in the High Court last year, where she won. The Commons still had not published the information before it started to be incompetently hawked around Fleet Street and partially leaked last month. Then the Telegraph somehow obtained the data and fearlessly published the choicest morsels via a circulation-boosting daily drip feed.

Poorly performing politicians deserve to be kicked out of office. They have all performed badly on the economy, wars and much else. But it is not the public that is venting its anger now. The public does not express its opinions through the media, much. Public opinions are only directly revealed by elections. 

Mainstream parties are right to fear the wrath of the public but wrong to assume there will be apathetic lynchings. Politicians that cannot give you a reason to vote for them do not deserve your vote. Give us something to vote for in a plan for the future. The political journalists will investigate the persons of MPs if they are not given any policies to scrutinise. The Westminster press pack might even start asking politicians the questions people really want answered.