Showing posts with label Joanna Lumley and Gordon Brown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joanna Lumley and Gordon Brown. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 May 2009

Attacking MPs is journalistic cowardice

Billions have been spent on banks that will not lend. The crisis in finance means the next government, whether under David Cameron or Joanna Lumley, will have to make savage cuts in public expenditure. But no politicians are talking about any of that until after the next General Election while the champions of the people in the media are letting them get away with it. They are checking receipts for second homes and moats.

Shaken politicians and excited reporters say public anger and disgust may destroy the foundations of trust that underpin democracy. Except that opinion polls don’t support this view. Support for all parties has hardly varied during the course of the affair so far.

The public is imagined in the minds of politicians and Westminster journalists as an unstable and unpredictable rabble. They fear the anger of the mob, but how, exactly, has this anger been expressed? A satirical website planted a pound-shaped flowerbed in an MP’s garden and some more were booed on Question Time. The public may be revolted, but it is not revolting. Some polls say people see the expenses issue as peripheral.

The media, led by The Daily Telegraph, has been humiliating MPs as part of a long-running feud. There is a strong blame culture involving the politicians we vote in to represent us directly and the media that scrutinise, edit and communicate what they do in our name. “Village” is an apt description of Westminster if it describes a parochial, paranoid place where scandal results from everyone knowing your business.

Both antagonists have trust and legitimacy problems. The media, especially its biggest British organisation, the BBC, can’t do anything right. Newspapers are declining, commercial TV is going broke and local media are endangered species. Journalists collecting and editing information on behalf of the public are representative, in fact, of the organisations that sell and exploit that information. Reporters must chase circulation and eyeballs, not the big picture.

Politicians are suspicious of the reporters’ agendas and try to channel and control communication through to their voters. The reporters must be seen to work under Jeremy Paxman’s maxim: “Why is this bastard lying to me?” The public, endowed with the many eyes and arms of the media, becomes capable of bringing about the downfall of politicians without recourse to the voter.

The politicians’ refusal to discuss the near future is cowardly.  The Tories, as the probable next government, are particularly craven. they are not trying to win the next election, ther're just sitting back, waiting for Gordon Brown to lose it. They spinelessly waffle about austerity while keeping quiet about unpopular policies.

Political journalists cannot even prod the Prime Minister-in-waiting to say what he will do in power. The media, led by that vanguard of the people, the Telegraph, take the government to task for its decoration bills while it runs up the biggest public debt ever – after a 15-year boom.

MPs’ expenses have taken a long and winding route to become a strange form of public property. Investigative journalist and author Heather Brooke tried to use the Freedom of Information Act to publish MPs’ expenses in 2004 and received such a run-around she ended up in the High Court last year, where she won. The Commons still had not published the information before it started to be incompetently hawked around Fleet Street and partially leaked last month. Then the Telegraph somehow obtained the data and fearlessly published the choicest morsels via a circulation-boosting daily drip feed.

Poorly performing politicians deserve to be kicked out of office. They have all performed badly on the economy, wars and much else. But it is not the public that is venting its anger now. The public does not express its opinions through the media, much. Public opinions are only directly revealed by elections. 

Mainstream parties are right to fear the wrath of the public but wrong to assume there will be apathetic lynchings. Politicians that cannot give you a reason to vote for them do not deserve your vote. Give us something to vote for in a plan for the future. The political journalists will investigate the persons of MPs if they are not given any policies to scrutinise. The Westminster press pack might even start asking politicians the questions people really want answered.

Monday, 11 May 2009

Do you wish Joanna Lumley was on your side?

I support the Gurkhas' victory against Gordon Brown and their winning the right to settle in Britain, but I can't accept the role Joanna Lumley has been given as their political spokesman and leader.

After campaigning for years, the Gurkhas appear to have snatched the prize from a crisis-ridden government by the masterful, strategic use of a comedy actor.

Lumley was magnificent: bellowing the war-cry in her beautiful posh accent; accosting ministers with irreproachable manners; and glamorously forcing the Prime Minister to back down. 

Brown's series of unfortunate events and his disastrous responses have been established as the political top story and easy narrative that pretends to explain everything as it happens. 

Lumley is supposed to have taken advantage of the situation and manipulated events to raise awareness of, and public sympathy for, the Gurkhas' cause.

Brown is supposed to have caved in under pressure from this public opinion, but the significant section of his Parliamentary party that did not back him was his more practical problem.

The public was not really involved in the Gurkhas' victory, however much the public may have supported the old soldiers.

The affair was enacted by its principle players, Lumley and the elderly Gurkhas, in the arranged gaze of the media and in scenes created for the media. Perhaps anticipating how the public perceived these performances, a number of Labour MPs dissented from the government's line.

Joanna Lumley raised awareness of the plight of the Gurkhas and starred in the media portrayal of that plight. She went on to improvise by buttonholing a minister in the street.

But the public functioned as a passive receiver of the campaign, as it had of the top story of the decline of Brown's administration. Those MPs of all parties who voted with the Gurkhas are under pressure from public opinion only as it will be expressed next year in the General Election. There was no public involvement in any of the events that led to the Gurkhas' demands being met.

Furthermore, the issues discussed were narrowed the more that the government backed down. 

Having originally objected to settling more Gurkhas in Britain on the bases of cost and the numbers of other claimants who might come forward, the government retreated by making the Gurkhas a special case, deserving of rights that accrue to them alone on the basis of their particular status as faithful colonial retainers.

I support the extension of rights to live in work in Britain because it is immoral and irrational to distinguish between people on the basis of their appearance or origins and because immigration has been very good for Britain and made it a better place - let 'em all in!

Joanna Lumley, 'daughter of the regiment', closed the discussion down to concentrate on the particular merits of British settlement for Gurkhas. That they had fought (fought?)  For Britain and therefore had the moral right to live here was the winning, morally undeniable coup de grace to Brown's resistance.

So while it's good that Gurkhas have settlement rights, those rights have been won in such a peculiar way that it will make campaigning against those immigration controls that had previously denied the Gurkhas' rights even more difficult.

If Joanna Lumley was on your side you could certainly expect cameras and media attention. You might hope to create public debate and support from the publicity. 

However, nothing like that happened with the Gurkhas. Their story and the merits of their claims became a dramatised example of a lame duck administration.

Perhaps your cause is one that can afford to be dislocated from wider issues where, as long as your particular demands are met, you will happily narrow the debate around it to a simple moral imperative. 

If you don't want to challenge the assumptions that have been the basis of resistance to your cause so far, then you do need Joanna Lumley on your side.

Perhaps celebrity involvement in campaigns may become more common now, but most things worth campaigning for involve the kinds of discussions that change people's minds or opinions.

Would you ask Joanna Lumley to speak for your cause on the basis of her expertise in the arguments and rhetoric of the issues involved?